Influencer Marketing vs. Traditional Advertising

May 9, 2023

Marketing has come a long way since the days of traditional advertising channels like television, radio and print media. In recent years, influencer marketing has become a powerful tool for companies to promote their products or services. But how does influencer marketing compare to traditional advertising channels? In this blog post, we will compare the pros and cons of both marketing formats

‍Advantages ofTraditional Advertising
‍Traditional
advertising channels have been around for decades and have proven to be effective in reaching a wide audience. Here are some of the advantages of traditional advertising:

  • Wide reach: Traditional advertising channels such as television, radio and print media have a wide reach and can reach a large number of people at once.
  • Established credibility: Traditional advertising channels are well established and familiar to people, which gives them a certain credibility.
  • Control: Advertisers have complete control over the content and placement of their ads in traditional advertising channels.

‍Disadvantages oftraditional advertising
‍The
traditional advertising channels have their advantages, but also some disadvantages:

  • High cost: Traditional advertising channels can be expensive, and small businesses may not have the budget to advertise on television or radio.
  • Limited targeting: Traditional advertising channels have limited targeting options. Advertisers can target a specific audience by selecting a time slot or publication, but they cannot target specific individuals.
  • Reduced effectiveness: With the advent of ad blocking software, traditional online advertising channels are losing effectiveness as people increasingly ignore or skip ads.

‍Advantagesof Influencer Marketing
‍Influencer
marketing has become increasingly popular in recent years due to the rise of social media. Here are some of the benefits of influencer marketing:

  • Targeted reach: Influencer marketing allows companies to target a specific audience based on the demographic makeup of the influencer's followers.
  • Young target group: younger generations are consuming fewer and fewer traditional media channels and are therefore less likely to be reached by advertising on these channels. This generation, on the other hand, are particularly active on social media and can be reached super via these channels.
  • Credibility: Influencers have established themselves as experts in their respective niches and have built up a loyal following, which gives them a certain degree of credibility.
  • Cost-effective: Influencer marketing can be cost-effective because companies can work with micro-influencers who charge less than well-known influencers.

‍Disadvantages ofInfluencer Marketing
‍Influencer
marketing has many advantages, but also some disadvantages:

  • Limited reach: Influencer marketing has limited reach compared to traditional advertising channels, and companies may need to partner with multiple influencers to reach a larger audience or supplement influencer marketing with paid social media ads.
  • Unpredictability: influencer marketing can be unpredictable because influencers don't always deliver the expected results and the success of the campaign can depend on factors such as the influencer's popularity and engagement rates.
  • Lack of control: unlike traditional advertising, companies do not have complete control over influencer-created content, which can be a disadvantage if the influencer does not align with the brand's values.

For these reasons, it is important to place great emphasis on recruiting the right influencers. The brand fit of the influencers and a detailed briefing on the company, the brand and the values it represents are essential.

In conclusion, both influencer marketing and traditional advertising have their advantages and disadvantages. Traditional advertising channels have a large reach and high credibility, but can be expensive and have limited options for addressing target groups. Influencer marketing, on the other hand, allows companies to target specific audiences and is cost-effective, but has limited reach and can be unpredictable. Ultimately, companies don't have to choose or reject one of the advertising mediums; they can use them in parallel. The decision whether influencer marketing or traditional advertising is more promising depends on the campaign goal, the budget, the target group and many other factors.

If you'd like to learn more about influencer marketing and how it can be applied at different stages of the marketing funnel, feel free to contact us at hallo@swissper.ch or book a call with one of our experts directly: Book a Call!